April 27, 2012 Leave a comment
Day 1 of the NFL draft is in the books and day 2 looms tonight. From a pure recap and review stand point the new draft format works a whole lot better. You can spend all day analyzing the first round picks and then move on to what will happen on Friday night in Rounds 2 and 3. Here’s a look at what I liked and didn’t like on Day 1:
I LIKED: The Patriots’ aggressiveness in Round 1. Their swindling pick system became obsolete with the new draft rules and so instead of finding trade partners to kick the ball down the road they reversed course and aggressively pursued their targets by trading up. They got two good young defensive guys to add to their front 7 although I seem to be in the minority in liking the Hightower pick more than the Jones pick. You just don’t find that versatility that Hightower possesses often.
- I DIDN’T LIKE: The pick of Ryan Tannehill from a football standpoint. I get why they did it and I can’t honestly say that I wouldn’t have done it if I were in their shoes but this guy just doesn’t do it for me. If he doesn’t pan out then it could set your franchise back for years. Is it worth it to get a few months worth of fan support? It certainly is desperately needed after the failures by Stephen Ross to woe coaches and quarterbacks to Miami. The only benefit of the doubt I will give them in that Mike Sherman, who was Tannehill’s college coach, is now the Offensive Coordinator in Miami so that may help Tannehill’s transition.
I LIKED: Buddy Nix staying true to his draft board again and not reaching for need. The Bills need a WR and LT the most but since they had Michael Floyd off of their board due to character issues there was no guy at those positions worth the #10 pick. It happens every year…two years ago it was Jimmy Clausen and Bryan Bulaga. If they took either one of those guys then they would still be looking at trying to find a QB and a LT since Clausen sucks and Bulaga plays the right side. Gilmore should be a great player in time and will get veteran leadership from Drayton Florence and Terrence McGee in the meantime.
- I DIDN’T LIKE: The Jets picking Quinton Coples over Melvin Ingram, Chandler Jones, or even Courtney Upshaw. Coples was seen as a top 10 pick during the college season but attitude and effort issues dropped him down the board. He also seems big to play OLB in the 3-4 which is what the Jets needed. The Ingram pass is the biggest mystery to me because I think Ingram is going to be a real player in the future. I can’t fault them too much for passing on Upshaw because everyone else did too but I still think he’ll be a player in the right situation.
- NON AFC EAST THINGS I LIKED ABOUT THE DRAFT LAST NIGHT: Loved Pittsburgh’s pick of David Decastro at #24, best pick of the night in my opinion. Just a perfect fit and there may not be a guy in the draft set up to contribute right away than DeCastro. Dallas made out by moving up to get Morris Claiborne at #6. Dre Kirkpatrick could be a steal for the Bengals if he pans out, his arrest helped Cincy with that one. They also got a good player in guard Kevin Zeitler with their 2nd 1st rounder. I think Melvin Ingram was a steal for San Diego at #18 as well.
NON AFC EAST THINGS I DIDN’T LIKE: I’m not sure about Dontari Poe going #11 to the Chiefs. Even factoring the systems I liked Fletcher Cox and Michael Brockers better. Whitney Mercilus was a one year wonder so Houston going with him was a bit of a surprise. I didn’t like the AJ Jenkins to San Fransisco pick although there is room for him to develop behind Moss and Manningham.
- WHAT TO LOOK FOR TONIGHT: What’s interesting is that the 3 AFC East teams that didn’t make the playoffs all have the same needs going into tonight. The Bills, Jets and Dolphins all need receivers and offensive tackles. The Pats have multiple picks and still need help in the secondary and could use some offensive line depth but they can add it anywhere, don’t necessarily need a tackle. Buffalo is up 1st with the 9th pick of Round 2 however any 1 of the other 3 teams can move up. As you saw last night that’s not hard to do these days. There are plenty of wide receivers and tackles at the early stages of the 2nd round so look for a lot of action there. The 3rd round seems so far away at this point but I’m sure the teams will be looking for whatever they didn’t get in Round 2. I am not bold enough to mock the next two rounds especially after all the movement of last night.